Being a big fan of the Magnum 46, I had great expectations of this cigar, and it did not disappoint.
Appearance 10/10
The appearance of the Magnum 46 is very good, but the Magnum 50 is a perfect looking cigar. The wrapper has the same lovely light chocolate colour to it, and like the 46 only has a few small veins. It may sound odd but this cigar is a perfect size, you cant miss it, its large but not too ostentatious, and feels great in your hand.
Construction & Draw 10.0/10
The construction of this cigar is absolutely excellent, the cap unlike many cigars appears to be a seamless part of the stick, not something of an after thought. The wrapper is just perfect, its slightly darker than the 46, and I think has a more oily texture. The draw on this cigar is spot on, because of the large ring gauge it has an easy draw, but it never feels to light or easy, so far I would say this cigar has the most perfect draw of any cigar I have smoked
The burn on this cigar is also amazingly clean, the burn line on the cigar was absolutely straight, as if it was begin cut by a laser! This cigar also produced masses of lovely grey smoke, to be honest I was glad I was smoking it outside (well sanding at the balcony doors), inside I would probably have not been able to see from one side of my lounge to the other.
Flavour 9.5/10
The cigar has a medium flavour, it started out quite spicy but quickly settled, and then I got distinct coffee and chocolate flavours coming through. What really impressed with this stick was that at different points I could taste when the flavour moved from coffee to chocolate, something I have not been able to do before (I just don’t think I have a sophisticated enough pallet). I would have given this cigar 10 if it had not started out with a little too much spice.
Value 9.0/10
This is not a cheap cigar, I paid 16 GBP for it, but compared to other cigars of its size and sophistication this does not seem bad value for money. At 4 GBP more than a Magnum 46, I think it offers pretty good value, and for me value is not just about cost its about how much pleasure I got for my money, and for that reason 9.0 is fair.
Summary 10/10
I have given this a 10, when reading the review you might question why it got this score and not a 9.5 or 9.0. Well whilst everything about this stick is not perfect, the overall experience is. I really enjoyed smoking this cigar, it looked great, felt great, had perfect draw, wonderful distinct flavors, and masses of fragrant smoke.
So for me although on paper it does not look like a 10, for me it was, and I would smoke this cigar every hour of every day if I could afford it !